"Ruthless gardening"

Time to re-appraise.
Sunday, 31 May 2020        

A chrysanthemum that is too floppy and has gone berserk: for the axe!

One of my favourite gardening writers, Vita Sackville-West, of Sissingurst fame, once wrote that the only way to garden is to be ruthless: 'The true gardener must be brutal, and imaginative for the future'. I think this time of year is a good one for evaluating your garden and deciding which plants you have may not be worthwhile keeping. It pays to be a bit hard-hearted about this process and to remember that every plant that is pulled out will give you space to put in a new one. This is relevant to me, as I have easily a hundred plants in pots waiting for homes!

There are no ironclad rules for how to decide if a plant should stay or go, but in walking around my garden this week, I came up with a few pointers that might help indicate where the axe should fall.

Plants that go berserk: this category includes creepers that cover everything in sight, perennials with vigorous, questing roots that want to take over whole garden beds, shrubs which grow too wide or trees that grow far too tall for a normal suburban backyard. Though I often have reassured myself as I plant one of these monsters, that of course I will keep it under control by judicious pruning or digging out unwanted bits that have wandered too far, the sad fact is that I often don't get around to it. These plants cause a lot of work, can smother other plants, and if left in the ground for too long, are almost impossible to get rid of. Be suspicious when someone wants to offer you a plant that 'grows really easily'. In our early, unconfident gardening days, this may seem like a positive attribute - but as we get more experience, we realise it is not! In my own garden, I am about to remove a lovely dusky red Phygelius cultivar, because what I fondly imagined to be a small and sedate shrubby perennial, has taken over at least a square metre of a garden bed, muscling out smaller, more fragile treasures.

Plants with poor form: although flowers are usually what attract us to a plant, we have to remind ourselves that they are transient, whereas the overall shape of the plant is there all year round. Although it is OK to have a modicum of plants that form an amorphous mass, if there are nothing but these, a garden is in danger of resembling nothing more than a collection of blobs. And if the plants are all herbaceous perennials, you are left with nothing at all in winter when they die down to become dormant. I like plants with a strong natural shape, but also enjoy clipped hedges and topiarised shapes to give structure to a garden. Sometimes poor form can be linked with a need for staking, and that also annoys me. I am about to remove the hybrid tree Dahlia 'Timothy Hammett' because it has no shape and is always falling over. Supposed to be a metre tall, it has grown to 3m and has no strength to holds itself up. It also leaves an ugly gap when it is cut back to the ground after flowering. Out it goes!

Plants that are out of their comfort zone: I know that many gardeners do enjoy the challenge of being able to grow cold-climate or truly tropical plants in Sydney and who am I to deny them that pleasure? There is a certain frisson in knowing you are probably one of the few people to be able to grow a lily-of-the-valley or a Heliconia in Sydney, but realistically, they will never look as happy as they would be in their preferred climate. These days I don't have time to spend cosseting such plants and find it hard to believe I once used to put ice cubes around plants that wanted a colder winter than ours! My earliest gardening efforts were based on English gardening books, and resulted in many failures because I was trying to grow plants suited to a climate totally unlike my own. When I discovered the wealth of plants from Central and South America, South Africa, Mexico and other warm lands that flourish in Sydney, I realised that we could create our own style of gardens that can look every bit as good as a lush English perennial border. And gardeners in cold climates envy us for what we can grow!

Plants with boring leaves: there are so many plants with lovely leaves that it seems a shame to grow any that have spitefully dull ones. Look for plants with beautifully shaped leaves, unusually coloured ones or those with wonderful tactile texture. Leaves are with us for far longer than flowers, so foliage should be a prime consideration when choosing a plant. It is worthwhile going round your garden and looking critically at the leaves of all your plants to see what contribution they are making to the scene.

Plants that look too much the same as other plants: this is a tricky one, because those of us with a passion for a particular genus of plants find ourselves adding to our collections, perhaps beyond the point of it being aesthetically pleasing. In fact, dare I say, the garden may start looking like a monoculture, and one of the rules of gardening that seems to be important is to have variety in shape and texture to give a satisfying look. In my own case, I have more than enough specimens of Salvia now and I have to start being very selective in adding any more. I am using some of the criteria outlines above to make this decision: ones that grow far too vigorously, have a poor shape or which are not thriving well are going to get the chop. With so many beautiful Salvia to pick from, we really can afford to be choosy and to pick the most attractive and well-behaved specimens to adorn our gardens.

As well as getting rid of substandard plants, this is a good time of year to move plants that are in the wrong position. As gardeners we always look towards the future to improve our gardens and live with the hope that next year, it will all look soooo much better!

This blog was originally published on 16 May 2010; updated 31 May 2020.

 Reader Comments

1/8  Carolyn - 2125 (Zone:10 - Warm Temperate) Sunday, 16 May 2010

Hi Deirdre, I totally agree with your sentiments on ruthless gardening. I have a tree dahlia which is only pretty for a week or two each year. Others I have struggled with for years and still they look straggly. I have great plans for renovations this winter.

Thanks, Carolyn. I agree re tree dahlias. They are quite ungainly and hard to stake. I think I am over them. Deirdre

2/8  Sue - 2073 (Zone:10 - Warm Temperate) Monday, 17 May 2010

Hi Deidre, At the weekend a weigela that had only flowered once in four years bit the dust to make way for a xanthostemon or Golden Penda which I had brought back from Coffs Harbour recently. They are planted as street trees up there . Fingers crossed that it will grow down here. Sue

Good luck with your new plant. I am going to chop out a Weigela too. Deirdre

3/8  Jan - 2072 (Zone:10 - Warm Temperate) Monday, 17 May 2010

Hi Deidre, Your timing is perfect yet again as I was wondering what do about my dianella that has taken over the garden. Now I know and it will be trimmed within an inch of its life and we will see what happens. Other than cordyline what do you suggest for red foliage. Jan.B.

Thanks, Jan. Some red foliage plants I grow are Iresine, Austromyrtus Blushing Beauty, the burgundy-leaf Loropetalum and Euphorbia cotinifolia. There are also bromeliads with red centres and some of the rhizomatous Begonia cultivars have interesting red stems. Deirdre.

4/8  Margaret - 2122 (Zone:10 - Warm Temperate) Tuesday, 18 May 2010

Agree with your philosophy! I am learning to be brutal, but am not sure about the imagination. I do know how to allow each plant its allotted space, and am starting from the back, and working my way to the front garden, trimming and culling. Thank you, as always, for your informative blogs.

You sound very systematic, Margaret! I think it is important to give each plant enough breathing space, otherwise they do get overgrown and can actually die from being smothered. It is hard, when we want to try so many things. But it is liberating to get rid of plants that are not really good enough, and gradually I do think our gardens improve that way. Deirdre.

5/8  Anne - 2605 (Zone:8-9 - Cool Temperate to Alpine) Monday, 01 June 2020

You are so right! I have Peruvian lilies which are true thugs. I just see years of digging the wretched things out. The drought controlled them but now they are smothering absolutely everything. Any ideas on how to do this ? Ugh, I have had them too. Diligent digging out is one way; or maybe try one of the new organic herbicides such as Slasher? Deirdre

6/8  Norman - 2653 (Zone:8-9 - Cool Temperate to Alpine) Monday, 01 June 2020

Hello i am taking out all periwinkle ground cover / thank you. I agree that is one that can take over! Deirdre

7/8  Bren - 2540 (Zone:10 - Warm Temperate) Monday, 01 June 2020

Good advice! I have a pergola covered in a rambling rose that I would love to get rid of. It's impossible to prune and has fluffy pink flowers for one week of the year. I hate fluffy pink. A bougainvillea would flower much of the year and add a tropical look, which I prefer to the English look. That Phygelius cultivar looks interesting, by the way! The bougainvillea would look good though they can grow pretty strongly too! But they provide colour for such a long period. The Phygelius is a pretty flower but I wouldn't recommend it - it is just too invasive. Deirdre

8/8  Pamela - 2158 (Zone:10 - Warm Temperate) Monday, 01 June 2020

Oh you could be writing about my garden. TOTALLY agree with everything you say. Even on a large garden I am ruthless. I am absolutely over the tree Dahlias and Ive relegated the smaller, what a joke, TH to my boundary fence! I am now moving so many Salvias out of my perennial borders as they have become huge maintenance and too big. If something isnt performing its out! I refuse to pamper plants, right plant right place as Beth Chatto always insisted. Great blog Deirdre Thanks, Pamela. I just don't have the energy for pampering temperamental plants any more. And ones that just require too much work. I enjoyed growing those huge salvias in my younger days but now I stick to ones that need less regular cutting back. I loved tree dahlias (and tree daisies and tree marigolds!!) once but now just admire them in other people's gardens! Deirdre

Make a comment

* You can only post comments on Blogs if you are signed in. If you are already registered please go to the Home page and Sign-In first. If you are not an iGarden member please click here to register now.

My eBooks (PDF)

Plant of the week

Most-recent blogs

A feast of berries
20 Jun 21
Berry-bearing plants can bring colour into our autumn and early winter gardens.

Gardening experiments
13 Jun 21
We can learn much about gardening by trying different methods.

Under the leaves
06 Jun 21
Raking autumn leaves from my garden beds, I discovered some nice surprises.

The art of layering
30 May 21
This is an intriguing way to make new plants!

Unexpected daisies
23 May 21
Here are some quite unusual 'daisy' plants!

Previously at this time

2010 - 30 May
2011 - 22 May
2012 - 20 May
2013 - 05 May
2014 - 25 May
2015 - 31 May
2017 - 28 May
2018 - 20 May
2019 - 19 May
2021 - 30 May

Sponsor message